| I Gotta Right to Sing the Blues | 3.12 | Harold Arlen & Ted Koehler | 13-Nov-57 |
| My Ideal | 2.40 | Chase, Robin & Whiting | |
| Why Don't I Get Wise to Myself * | 2.42 | Sid Bass & Ken Hecht | |
| I'm Glad for Your Sake * | 3.10 | Jack Lawrence & Peter Tinturin | |
| I Love You | 2.34 | Harland Thompson & Harry Asher | 30-Oct-57 |
| A Tree in the Meadow | 3.30 | Billy Reid | |
|
Side Two |
|||
| I Like the Sunrise | 3.20 | Duke Ellington | |
| There Is No Greater Love | 2.54 | Isham Jones & Marty Symes | 30-Oct-57 |
| I Can't Escape from You * | 2.40 | Lee Robin & Richard A. Whiting | 29-Oct-57 |
| I'll Be Around | 3.08 | Alec Wilder | |
| I Surrender Dear * | 3.02 | Harry Barris & Gordon Clifford | |
| It's the Talk of the Town | 3.06 | Jay Livingston, Al J. Neiburg & Marty Symes | 13-Nov-57 |
