Mine All Mine - Unchained Melody
| I Ain't Got Nothin' But The Blues | 2.38 | 1945 | Victor 20-1623 |
| I Can't Escape from You | 2.40 | 1958 |
Torchy and Blue |
| I Can't Put My Arms Around A Memory | 2.17 | 1955 | Decca - 29543 |
| I Can't Put My Arms Around A Memory | 2.48 | 1964 |
Early One Morning |
| I Complain | 2.30 | 1957 | Decca - 30337 |
| I Cried For You | 3.10 | 1984 | For Sentimental Reasons |
| I Don't Stand A Ghost Of A Chance With You | 3.07 | 1956 | Starring Al Hibbler |
| I Got It Bad And That Ain't Good | 3.05 | 1946 | Aladdin - 154 |
| I Got It Bad | 3.07 | 1961 |
Monday Every Day |
| I Gotta Right To Sing the Blues | 3.12 | 1958 | Torchy and Blue |
| I Hadn't Anyone Till You | 2.49 | 1957 | Here's Hibbler |
| I Let A Song Go Out Of My Heart | 2.41 | 1954 |
Norgran - 105 |
| I Like The Sunrise | 3.05 | 1949 | Columbia CL-6073 |
| I Like The Sunrise | 3.20 | 1958 |
Torchy and Blue |
| I Love You | 2.30 | 1949 | Sunrise - 515 |
| I Love You | 2.34 | 1958 |
Torchy and Blue |
| I Surrender Dear | 2.43 | 1947 | Aladdin - 156 |
| I Surrender Dear | 3.02 | 1958 |
Torchy and Blue |
| I Was Telling Her About You | 2.56 | 1956 | Decca - 29982 |
| I Was Telling Her About You | 4.15 | 1984 | For Sentimental Reasons |
| I Won't Tell A Soul I Love You | 3.12 | 1956 | After the Lights Go Down Low |
| If I Knew You Were There | 2.59 | 1951 | Atlantic - 932 |
| I'll Be Around | 3.08 | 1958 | Torchy and Blue |
| I'll Be Home For Christmas | 2.46 | 1981 | Christmas With Al Hibbler |
| I'll Get Along Somehow | 2.56 | 1957 | Here's Hibbler |
| I'll Never Smile Again | 2.55 | 1959 | Al Hibbler Remembers |
| I'm A Fool To Want You | 3.31 | 1961 | Monday Every Day |
| I'm Falling For You | 3.27 | 1959 | Al Hibbler Remembers |
| I'm Free | 2.50 | 1956 | Decca - 30100 |
| I'm Getting Sentimental Over You | 3.34 | 1954 |
Clef - 89095 |
| I'm Glad for Your Sake | 3.10 | 1958 | Torchy and Blue |
| I'm Glad I'm Not Young Anymore | 2.52 | 1958 | Decca - 30547 |
| I'm Gonna Sit Right Down And Write Myself A Letter | 2.18 | 1964 | Early One Morning |
| I'm Gonna Sit Right Down And Write Myself A Letter | 3.05 | 1984 | For Sentimental Reasons |
| I'm Just A Lucky So And So | 3.07 | 1946 | Victor 20-1799 |
| I'm Just A Lucky So And So | 2.54 | 1954 |
Norgran - 114 |
| I'm Just A Lucky So And So | 4.20 | 1964 | Early One Morning |
| I'm Walking Through Heaven With You | 2.42 | 1959 | Al Hibbler Remembers |
| I've Convinced Everyone But Me | 2.49 | 1962 | Reprise - 20077 |
| In The Wee Small Hours Of The Morning | 2.45 | 1961 | Monday Every Day |
| It Don't Mean A Thing | 3.01 | 1951 | Chess 1455 |
| It Must Be True | 2.12 | 1953 | Mercury - 89046 |
| It Shouldn't Happen To A Dream | 3.00 | 1947 | Musicraft 484 |
| (It) Shouldn't Happen To A Dream | 3.05 | 1954 | Al Hibbler Sings Duke Ellington |
| It Shouldn't Happen To A Dream | 4.45 | 1964 | Early One Morning |
| It Won't Be Easy | 2.45 | 1959 | Decca - 30946 |
| It's Been A Long, Long Time | 2.57 | 1957 |
Here's Hibbler |
| It's Love I'm In | 3.12 | 1969 | FDC 1022 |
| It's Monday Every Day | 3.02 | 1948 | Columbia 38165 |
| It's Monday Every Day | 2.41 | 1961 | Monday Every Day |
| It's The Talk Of The Town | 3.06 | 1958 | Torchy and Blue |
| Jelly, Jelly | 3.28 | 1959 | Al Hibbler Remembers |
| Jingle Bells | 1.49 | 1981 | Christmas With Al Hibbler |
| Just A Kid Named Joe | 3.14 | 1957 | Here's Hibbler |
| Laughing On The Outside | 3.30 | 1961 |
Monday Every Day |
| Let Me Dream | 2.41 | 1956 |
Sings Love Songs |
| Let's Make The Most Of A Beautiful Thing | 2.41 | 1967 | Vegas - 711 |
| Let's Try Again | 2.43 | 1956 | Decca - 29789 |
| Lonesome And Cold | 2.31 | 1959 | Decca - 30946 |
| Look Away | 2.30 | 1961 | Reprise - 20035 |
| Love Land | 2.43 | 1958 | Decca - 30752 |
| Love Me Long, Hold Me Close, Kiss Me Warm And Tender | 2.20 | 1958 | Decca - 30752 |
| Lover Come Back To Me | 2.49 | 1948 | Sunrise - 2119 |
| Lover Come Back To Me | 2.45 | 1964 | Early One Morning |
| Lover Come Back To Me | 3.49 | 1972 | A Meeting Of The Times |